Boca Raton Probate Litigation Attorney

A Boca Raton Probate Litigation Attorney Can Help Ease the Stress of Your Probate Disputes

Probate is the legal term for the administration of a decedent’s estate.  This process ordinarily involves admitting the decedent’s last will and testament and appointing a personal representative (also known as an executor) to oversee the administration process.  A fundamental part of a personal representative’s duties is the marshaling of probate assets for eventual distribution to the beneficiaries of the estate. Often times, disagreements arise in the course of this process, necessitating the retention of a Boca Raton probate litigation attorney.

Not everyone needs to hire a probate litigation lawyer. Most estates — especially those that have benefited from sound estate planning — can go through probate without incident. But the reality is that disputes do arise among heirs and beneficiaries of estates and trusts. In the cases where disagreements rise to the level that a court must intervene, an Ellis Law Group Boca Raton probate litigation attorney will help you protect your rights.

Ellis Law Group, P.L. is a Boca Raton probate litigation law firm offering solutions in all types of estate disputes. Contact us today to learn more about how we can assist your family in resolving probate matters.

Types of Florida Probate and Trust Litigation Matters

When people think of probate litigation, challenging a will or trust usually is the first thing that comes to mind. But trust and estates litigation can involve any contested issue that arises in the administration of trusts and estates that is argued in court. The most common types of matters that require the assistance of a Boca Raton probate litigation attorney include will and trust contests, suits alleging wrongdoing by trustees and executors/personal representatives, construction proceedings (that is, matters to determine the meaning and effect of the terms contained in an estate planning document), elective share litigation and other disputes concerning spousal rights, determining heirs and beneficiaries, and disputes surrounding accounting matters.  The term can also include litigation concerning other documents which purport to designate beneficiaries upon death, such as bank account titling documents and real property deeds.

Will and Trust Contests.

A will or trust contest is a formal objection to the validity of the document at issue, usually based on an allegation of one or more of the following:

  • The will or trust is invalid because it was not executed according to law
  • The testator/settlor (the person who executed the document) lacked mental capacity at the time the document was discussed and/or signed
  • The document is the product of undue influence 
  • The document is a forgery or is otherwise the product of fraud

These same arguments are also often made in disputes involving account beneficiary designation forms and real property deeds.

Breach of Fiduciary Duty.

The fiduciary of an estate (personal representative or executor) and trust (trustee) owes numerous duties to its beneficiaries.  These include duties of loyalty, a duty to account and inform, and a duty to prudently administer.  Likewise, beneficiaries of estates and trusts have rights and entitlements and can hold the fiduciary accountable if these rights are violated or if the fiduciary breaches its duties.  Fiduciary litigation offers beneficiaries whose rights have been violated myriad remedies when fiduciaries are guilty of misconduct.  These remedies can include the return of misappropriated assets, the removal of the fiduciary, and can also result in the fiduciary being required to account for its actions.

Will and Trust Construction.

A construction matter may end up in probate litigation when the terms of the will or trust are vague or subject to multiple interpretations.  In these proceedings court proceedings are necessary to resolve the disputed issues. 

  • Elective share. Absent a valid pre- or post-marital agreement, a surviving spouse in Florida has an absolute right to a share of the deceased spouse’s assets known as the elective share.. This type of matter might end up before a probate judge if the elective share is being withheld from a spouse or if the estate administrator contests that the amount is owed to the spouse. 
  • Determination of heirs. Sometimes, when a decedent dies intestate, the court must become involved in identifying the heirs to the estate. 
  • Accounting. A beneficiary of an estate can bring an action in probate court against a personal representative for an accounting of estate assets. 

Re-Titled and Wrongfully Transferred Assets/Depleted Estate

One of the fundamental tenets of probate is that a decedent’s will only controls the disposition and distribution of probate assets.  Probate assets are, in essence, those assets owned by the decedent which are not co-owned with rights of survivorship and which do not have any designated beneficiaries.  Often times, usually late in a decedent’s lifetime, the titling of assets changes or assets are transferred in a manner which results in a reduction in value of the estate.  For instance, a bank account once held in the decedent’s name alone is retitled such that it is held by the decedent and his or her son as joint tenants with rights of survivorship.  In some cases. substantial funds from a large account are transferred, without rhyme or reason, shortly before the decedent’s death.  It is also not uncommon that a family member becomes a signatory on a decedent’s account and abuses that power for personal gain by using the decedent’s assets for personal purposes.

In many of these cases, the manner in which these assets are transferred or retitled is profoundly at odds with the terms of the decedent’s will, thereby suggesting that the decedent did not legitimately intend for these transactions to occur.

Probate courts are courts of equity, which means that the judges who preside over estate matters look past the form of a transaction or asset in order to determine the true substance or truth.  When assets have been improperly retitled or transferred, or when a decedent’s funds have been spent down without the decedent’s consent, probate courts can and do find that these assets are, legally speaking, still part of the probate estate.  Courts have the power to order the return of these assets to the estate either through subsequent retitling or the delivery of funds. In addition, where an individual who is a beneficiary of the estate is found to have committed this type of wrongdoing, the court can find that the beneficiary’s interest in the estate has been satisfied to the extent of the unjust enrichment.

It is incumbent on those adversely affected by these acts to protect themselves, and to do so within various limitations periods imposed by Florida law. A Boca Raton probate litigation attorney at the Ellis Law Group is available for clients throughout Florida to consult in matters such as these.

Spousal Rights

Elective Share

Florida law provides that a spouse cannot be disinherited by will.  The only way a surviving spouse can be disinherited is through the execution of a valid premarital or postmarital agreement.  In the absence of a nuptial agreement, a surviving spouse is, at a minimum, entitled to an elective share.

As with other rights and interests in an estate, a qualifying spouse’s right to take an elective share must be exercised within the prescribed time.  In most cases, a spouse will be required to exercise this right within 6 months of being served with Notice of Administration but in any case, the right must be exercised within two years of the decedent’s death.

In Florida, the elective share is defined as 30 percent of the elective estate.  Florida subscribes to an “enhanced elective estate” system.  Even though an elective share is calculated as part of the probate process, the assets which ultimately form and fund the elective share may include assets which are not probate assets.  Florida law provides that the following non-probate assets are included in the elective estate from which the elective share is taken: the decedent’s fractional interest in jointly held property; the decedent’s interest in his or her homestead property; the decedent’s interest in assets with a designated beneficiary; the cash surrender value of certain policies of life insurance; and certain transfers of property made within a year of the decedent’s death.

It is the personal representative’s responsibility to put together the inventory of assets which form the elective estate and to set forth what the estate believes the value of the elective share is.  Both the spouse and the beneficiaries are afforded the right to object to this information. Potential grounds for objection are that certain includable assets were not disclosed in the inventory or that assets were improperly valued.  If disagreements cannot be amicably resolved, probate litigation may ensue.

Pretermitted Spouse

In some cases, a decedent makes his will before marriage and does not thereafter execute a new will naming his or her spouse as a beneficiary.  When the surviving spouse married the decedent after the will was made and the spouse is not named in the will, the spouse may be pretermitted. A pretermitted spouse is entitled to a share of the estate equal to that which the spouse would have received if the decedent died without a will.  Depending on the facts and circumstances, this would either be half or all of the probate estate. Unlike an elective share, the inheritance to a pretermitted spouse is made up exclusively of probate assets.

Other Spousal Rights

In addition to elective share, Florida law may confer other rights on surviving spouses.  One such right is the right to exempt property. As the name suggests, exempt property is exempt from the claims of creditors and is distributed to a spouse in addition to any other bequests.  That is, exempt property does not count towards satisfaction of an elective share or bequests made in a will. This right must be timely exercised, or it is waived. The deadline to claim exempt property will depend on the attendant facts and circumstances.

A surviving spouse may also be able to claim family allowance, which provides for the distribution of probate assets in an amount not to exceed $18,000.00 to allow a surviving spouse to pay his or her personal expenses while administration is ongoing.

The Boca Raton probate litigation lawyers at Ellis Law Group can assist surviving spouses in all probate matters, whether or not litigation is involved, in order to protect their elective share, pretermitted spousal share, and other rights.

Contact an Experienced Boca Raton Probate Litigation Attorney Today

If you and your loved ones are struggling with a probate dispute, a Boca Raton probate litigation attorney at Ellis Law Group can offer you the experienced and compassionate legal representation you need. Contact us online or by phone at 561-910-7500.

Latest News

What Does a Trust Administrator Do?

Fri May 29, 2020

When it comes to estate planning, trusts offer a number of advantages over a traditional will and have become an incredibly popular estate planning tool throughout the state of Florida. A trust works by naming a trustee to manage your assets for the benefit of your heirs. While this sounds […]

Full Read

Plan for Your Senior Years with a Living Trust

Fri May 15, 2020

Estate planning is essential if you want to protect your future and your family’s financial security. If you wait until you are unable to make decisions, your assets may not be distributed how you would like them to be. A lack of estate planning can also lead to disputes, unnecessary […]

Full Read

Understanding Probate Litigation

Tue Mar 31, 2020

The probate process can be difficult enough on its own, but it can become entirely overwhelming when it deteriorates into litigation. The emotions of the parties can make a probate dispute especially acrimonious and the parties sometimes forfeit their rights rather than get the dispute resolved. If you’re involved in […]

Full Read
More News